1920s Brownies

David
Wed, 09/24/2014 - 21:18
prevnextoldernewer
1920s Brownies

When: Here's the back -

Back of photo

The stamp-box, AZO with two triangles up and two triangles down, dates the picture to between 1910 and 1930 [1].

Next the Hong Kong Girl Guides website helps us narrow the range. It says that "The first Company in Hong Kong was formed in the Victoria British School [in 1916]" [2]. But the girls in the photo are Brownies (younger than Guides), so when did they first appear? The earliest result from a search for brownie in the HKGRO and local newspapers is 1922.

It looks as though Brownie Packs got going in Hong Kong the 1920s. With a range of 1920-1930 to choose from, I'll guess the middle, c.1925.

What: Do we have any ex-Brownies reading, who can explain what we're looking at? The centerpiece is the shape of an opened umbrella, and decorated with a pixie-like creature:

Centrepiece

And several of the girls are holding sticks with the same sort of creature on the end:

Sticks

Who / Where: If we know which Pack we're looking at we'll know where they are, and vice-versa. Packs first - the annual Education Report for 1922 [3] says:

The Peak and Wanchai Brownie Packs were maintained, and a new Pack was started at Kowloon. The total average enrolment was about 50.

Next year's 1923 report [4] says "There are at present [...] five packs of Brownies (children under 11)" and lists them as:

  • 1st Kowloon Co.
  • 2nd Kowloon Co.
  • 1st Murray Co. [Children of servicemen in the British Garrison]
  • 1st Wanchai
  • Peak

Then a newspaper article from 1926 [5] gives an update, listing only four Packs:

  • Peak
  • Garrison School
  • Quarry Bay
  • Kowloon

If no-one recognises the Pack, how about the buildings in the background? Extra clues are the flagpole on the right:

Flagpole

And the grass, which looks as though it is marked out for sports:

Sports Field

Any ideas?

Regards, David

References:

  1. Playle's "Real Photo Postcard Stamp Boxes, A-B"
  2. Hong Kong Girl Guides' website
  3. 1922 Annual Report for Education, see appendix G, "Report of the Organising Secretary, Girl Guides"
  4. 1923 Annual Report for Education, see appendix G, "Report of the Organising Secretary, Girl Guides"
  5. Page 5, Hong Kong Daily Press, 1926-08-26

Reference: EC038

Date picture taken
1925
Tags
Brownies
Gallery
1920s Hong Kong

Comments

The umbrella-like object is a Brownie toadstool. We had one for our Nuwara Eliya Brownie pack in 1950s Ceylon. Brownies (the supernatural variety) were supposed to dance around a toadstool and it is an essential piece of equipment for a Brownie pack. This Hong Kong one is smarter than ours was. I expect more recent Brownies can give you more detail about the song or chant that you sing as you dance round the toadstool.

Jill

Moddsey,

Yes, it was sold as a Hong Kong photo. It's not 100% sure of course, but the plants in the background look right for out here.

Jill,

Thanks for the extra info about the toadstool and the "sticks". I was a cub scout, where it was all a lot simpler - just a different coloured plastic ring around the neckerchief (a "woggle", if I remember correctly) to identify which six you belonged to.

Regards, David

I was a member of the Quarry Bay Brownie pack in 1966, and was a Pixie. That is probably what the sticks represent, there were four groups, Elves (Blue), Pixies (Green), Fairies (Yellow) and a red group I cannot recall.

Recently viewed at an auction house website. Same group of girls. The back of the photo postcard which is similar to David's says Hong Kong. Looking at the building on the left, I am not too sure. Anyways, good for discussion.

 

1920s Brownies Part 2
1920s Brownies Part 2, by Moddsey

Had previously read up on the visit of the Prince of Wales. There was an inspection of 'wolfcubs' and 'brownies' at Government House on the first day of the visit to Hong Kong. Page 9 of the China Mail dated 6 April 1922 refers. The following day, there was an inspection of school children from different schools at the Cricket Ground.

There is a link within gwulo of the 1st Kowloon Brownies

https://gwulo.com/atom/20462

...where a hypothesis was put forward that the grounds of the old Kowloon or Central British School next to St Andrew’s church on Nathan Road was used as a similar photo showing the prefects of the school in 1934 in same ground. 

Certainly the flat-ish terrain would suggest Kowloon side as the more likely location cf Hong Kong

The builidng type, flagpole and sports ground would suggest the buildings unlikey used for purely residential purposes but more communal use (school? clubhouse?) Some damage noted on the mat shed type roofing over verandah on the right of photo (post-typhoon or heavy rain damage?). No leaves on the trees and girls wearing long sleeved clothing and women heavy frocks suggest winter time when photo taken. 

 

 

 

That's a great photo! I was gloomy that no photos of 1920s Hong Kong Girl Guides had yet emerged on Gwulo, but I think I can just make them out in the background. The sartorial combination worn by the Chief Commissioner (Rev. G.T. Waldegrave?) of shorts, knee socks and dog collar is rather impressive! I imagine the lady walking behind the Prince is the troop leader of the Guides - perhaps Miss Reed? I will dig out a 1922ish photo of Evelyn Warren at the races standing next to a gentleman in a dog collar, but probably not Waldegrave. I'm most grateful to you and also to David for spotting Evelyn's involvement in the Hong Kong Girl Guides, which I would otherwise never have known about.