Calling photo sleuths: where is this photo?

Submitted by CityUnseen on

There's a photo of a street scene in HKU Library's Frank Fischbeck collection that claims to be somewhere in Hong Kong in the 1920s but I suspect it might not be. 

Photo link here

My reasons: 

  1. The wooden utility poles don't look like Hong Kong. I know Hong Kong Electric stopped doing overhead power lines in 1905, but since this is supposed to be the 1920s they could be telephone poles. All the other telephone poles I've seen in pictures of old Hong Kong were metal. However, I could be wrong here, I don't know whether CLP had overhead wires in Kowloon or when they undergrounded them.
  2. There's a sign on the left that reads in Chinese "Guangzhou City Long Distance Bus Service". I doubt Hong Kong had a bus service to Guangzhou in the 1920s. If it existed, the route would've been very roundabout since the only road crossing was at Sha Tau Kok.
  3. It's possible the photo was misdated but if this was taken in Hong Kong after the 1920s there wouldn't have been any telephone poles, as they were taken down by the late 1920s.
  4. One of the pillars on the right side of the street reads "Zhongshan Sea and Land Military Uniforms," which does not sound like Hong Kong.

 

My guess is that this was taken somewhere in Guangdong Province, probably Zhongshan. Any ideas?

 

Yes, the electricity poles suggest that it is not a Hong Kong scene.

A quick google of the bus stop sign on the left in the main photo shows another signage on the Bund in Canton: https://picryl.com/search?q=Bus%20Stop%20Canton%20-%20%E4%B8%AD%E5%9C%8B%E6%AD%B7%E5%8F%B2%E5%9C%96%E7%89%87%EF%BC%8C%E7%B6%AD%E5%9F%BA%E5%AA%92%E9%AB%94 (Click twice)

Or: https://picryl.com/media/bus-stop-the-bund-canton-863f7a

(The photo on the left on "picryl" comes from the same photo held by the Hong Kong University Digital Repository)

Telephone pole, by tkjho

China Electric Company was the contractor, not China Light and Power Co.

The caption on the main photo on picryl indicates "廣東省城(廣州)馬路邊上的廣州市長途搭客汽車停車處(供加拿大車使用)" - Canton City roadside car stop for Canton City long distance passenger cars (for Canadian cars).

It's Canton, not Hong Kong.